The 10 Most Valuable Paul Coffey Hockey Cards

Summary

• Paul Coffey's hockey cards are highly sought after for nostalgic and investment purposes.
• Coffey's autographed cards, like the 2015 Upper Deck Limited Logos, are considered some of the most valuable in the card world.
• Coffey's cards hold nostalgic and investment value, particularly in prestigious sets like The Cup and SP Authentic series.

Born in 1961, Paul Coffey is a former Canadian professional hockey player, widely regarded as one of the greatest defensemen in NHL history. He was part of the legendary Edmonton Oilers roster throughout the 1980s, contributing significantly to the team's Stanley Cup victories during that period.

15 Hockey Games For People Tired Of The NHL Series

After over 20 years of steady releases, a long-time buyer can start to suffer from NHL fatigue.

Recognized as one of the most valuable defensive players in NHL history, Coffey's cards hold significant importance in the hockey card world, making them highly sought after in the collector’s market. His cards are both nostalgic and valuable for investment purposes. Signed cards, being rarer, hold even more prestige and are considered some of the most valuable in the card world. Here, we list Coffey's most valuable cards.

The value of trading cards depends on the condition of the card. The values listed may differ from an appraiser's quote. All metrics were compiled by Collectibles.com.

10 2015 Upper Deck The Cup #36 Paul Coffey

Variation

Base

Card Number

36

Lowest Price

$383 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$383 (Ungraded)

As one of the most prestigious NHL-licensed sets, The Cup stands out with its high-end materials, low print runs, and autographed rookie cards of star players. While the undisputed crown jewel of the 2015-16 set is the Connor McDavid Rookie Patch Autograph, Paul Coffey's card also holds significant value.

Often referred to as the 'Holy Grail' of NHL card collecting, The Cup boxes are expensive, but the potential for pulling highly valuable cards attracts collectors worldwide. In this set, Coffey appears in 'Legend' status, honoring his legacy as one of the greatest defensemen in NHL history. His inclusion adds both nostalgic and investment-worthy appeal for collectors.

9 2015 Upper Deck The Cup Limited Logos Autographed Patch #LL-PC Paul Coffey

Variation

Limited Logos Autographed Patch

Card Number

LL-PC

Lowest Price

$386.3 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$386.3 (Ungraded)

This subset features some of the most striking cards that reflect the premium design and content quality of The Cup series. The card’s most distinctive feature is its large and visually striking patch. In addition, the front of the card showcases Paul Coffey’s hard-signed autograph.

With a thick card stock and high-quality printing, this card stands out in both craftsmanship and rarity. Only 25 copies were produced, making it especially rare for a legend like Coffey. It is a highly sought-after piece for both Coffey fans and general Legend collectors. This card carries strong nostalgic appeal as well as high investment and collection value.

8 2011 SP Game Used Extra SIGnificance #XSIG-GC Wayne Gretzky / Paul Coffey

Variation

Extra SIGnificance

Card Number

XSIG-GC

Lowest Price

$444.92 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$444.92 (Ungraded)

This card is part of a special autograph subset from Upper Deck’s SP Game Used series. It holds strong collectible value both within the set and for the featured players individually. Featuring dual autographs from Wayne Gretzky and Paul Coffey, the card presents a sleek composition with classic SP Game Used design elements.

Best Couch Co-Op Sports Games

Many sports games have been released over the years, but these are the best for couch co-op fun.

Both players are among the greatest in NHL history, and having their signatures on the same card is a rare and remarkable occurrence. Their shared time as teammates on the Edmonton Oilers adds nostalgic and historical significance. With only 25 copies produced, the card’s scarcity further enhances its collectible appeal.

7 2011 SP Game Used Triple SIGnificance #3SIG-OIL Wayne Gretzky / Jari Kurri / Paul Coffey

Variation

Triple SIGnificance

Card Number

3SIG-OIL

Lowest Price

$473.81 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$493.15 (BGS 8.5)

Published by Upper Deck, this card is part of the SP Game Used series and features exclusive autographs from three legendary players in Edmonton Oilers history. Limited to only ten copies, the front of the card showcases images and authentic signatures of Paul Coffey, Wayne Gretzky, and Jari Kurri.

This iconic trio helped define the Oilers as one of the dominant teams of the 1980s. The card represents Coffey’s unique contributions during that era, both defensively and offensively. His presence on this card not only honors him as one of the greatest players in Oilers history but also as one of the most outstanding defensemen in NHL history.

6 2015 SP Authentic Sign Of The Times 4 #ST4-EDM Wayne Gretzky / Grant Fuhr / Paul Coffey / Glenn Anderson

Variation

Sign of the Times 4

Card Number

ST4-EDM

Lowest Price

$486.02 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$559.5 (Ungraded)

This card is a highly special and rare quad autograph from Upper Deck's prestigious SP Authentic series. Along with Paul Coffey, the autographs of Wayne Gretzky, Grant Fuhr, and Glenn Anderson are featured. The card is themed around the Edmonton Oilers, the iconic team of the 1980s.

With an extremely limited print run, the front of the card showcases photos of the four players along with their on-card signatures. It is extremely rare to see such a group of legendary players on the same card. As the team's star defenseman, Coffey played a crucial role in the Oilers' dominance during the 1980s, contributing significantly to their defensive strength and offensive records.

5 2011 Upper Deck The Cup Enshrinements Triple #CE3-EDM Mark Messier / Wayne Gretzky / Paul Coffey

Variation

Enshrinements Triple

Card Number

CE3-EDM

Lowest Price

$860.01 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$860.01 (Ungraded)

This card is part of Upper Deck’s prestigious high-end hockey series, The Cup, and features three autographs from legendary players. The Enshrinements Triple subset honors Hall of Fame inductees with premium, high-quality signed cards. This ultra-rare card showcases three Edmonton Oilers icons, and having all their signatures on a single card makes it exceptionally valuable in the collecting world.

12 Sports Games With The Best Career Mode

Rise to the top with some of the best career modes ever made.

It appeals to both sentimental and investment-minded collectors, elevating it to near 'holy grail' status for Oilers fans and NHL history enthusiasts alike. These three players formed the legendary core of the 1980s Oilers, leading the team to multiple Stanley Cup championships.

4 2022 SP Authentic Sign Of The Times 3 #SOTT3-PIT Paul Coffey / Mario Lemieux / Jaromir Jagr

Variation

Sign of the Times 3

Card Number

SOTT3-PIT

Lowest Price

$515 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$887.11 (PSA 9)

This card belongs to the 2022-23 Upper Deck SP Authentic series and brings together three legendary Pittsburgh Penguins players: Paul Coffey, Mario Lemieux, and Jaromir Jagr. Only 15 copies of this card were produced, making it a rare and unique piece for collectors.

Featuring three of the greatest players in NHL history, this card holds significant emotional and financial value. Paul Coffey’s offensive defense skills, Mario Lemieux’s hockey IQ, and Jaromir Jagr’s long career make this card highly desirable. Coffey’s presence on this card honors his contributions to the Penguins’ offensive defense and his role in their 1991 Stanley Cup championship, making it especially valuable for his fans and Penguins collectors.

3 2021 SP Authentic Sign Of The Times 8 #SOTT8-EGHT

Variation

Sign of the Times 8

Card Number

SOTT8-EGHT

Lowest Price

$910 (PSA 9 8)

Highest Price

$1,265.82 (Ungraded)

This card is from the Upper Deck SP Authentic series, specifically the Sign of the Times 8, and is a rare and prestigious collectible that brings together some of the greatest players in NHL history. Only five copies of this card were produced, featuring legendary names who achieved great success in their careers.

Paul Coffey’s inclusion on this card highlights his defensive contributions to the Edmonton Oilers. Additionally, it honors his role in the team’s success during the 1980s and 1990s. On this card, Coffey is celebrated not only for his importance in Oilers history but also for his significant role in NHL history.

This isn’t just a 'Paul Coffey card'—it’s a Gretzky-led, eight-player masterpiece celebrating the Oilers’ dynasty, featuring Wayne Gretzky, Mike Bossy, Steve Yzerman, Patrick Roy, Ray Bourque, Paul Coffey, Mike Gartner, and Cam Neely.

2 2017 Upper Deck The Cup 9-Way Signature Booklets #9W-EO

Variation

9-Way Signature Booklets

Card Number

9W-EO

Lowest Price

$1,524 (Ungraded)

Highest Price

$1,524 (Ungraded)

This card features nine legendary players from the Edmonton Oilers, making it a rare and prestigious collectible. It is part of a set where each card is produced in a limited run of just nine copies. Each player’s signature is included on the card, making it highly valuable and sought after by both Oilers fans and collectors.

Due to the limited production, the prestige and value of this card have risen accordingly. Paul Coffey’s inclusion honors his defensive contributions to the Oilers and his role in the team’s success.

This card is a rare booklet from the 2017 Upper Deck The Cup 9-Way Signature Booklets set, featuring signatures from nine legendary Edmonton Oilers players. The players included are Wayne Gretzky, Jari Kurri, Mike Krushelnyski, Mark Messier, Glenn Anderson, Laurie Boschman, Paul Coffey, Grant Fuhr, and Andy Moog.

1 1981 O-Pee-Chee #111 RC Paul Coffey

This set holds a significant place among NHL collectors and features some of the most iconic hockey cards of the era. One of the key cards in this set is Wayne Gretzky’s card, which was produced during the period when his career was reaching its peak, making it highly valuable.

Comprising 396 cards, this set also includes Paul Coffey’s card, which marks an important point in his career. It represents his early NHL years and the foundation of his success with the Oilers. While not one of the most prominent cards in the set, Coffey’s card reflects his major role in NHL history.

The 1981 O-Pee-Chee #111 is Paul Coffey's rookie card, marking the beginning of his NHL career.