Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 will test you to create a morally challenging decision in the “Necessary Evil” quest. This involves making a crucial choice on whom you would side with: Hashek or Olda Semine. So, here’s a Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 Semine choices guide.
Getting Information About Semine’s Involvement
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 Semine storyline starts with the interrogation of a captured bandit. You’ll have to pick between persuasion or torture to find out information about Olda Semine. This crucial information determines his involvement with local bandits to conduct their raids.
With this knowledge, it’ll now lead you to your first major decision between keeping silent or being honest. You’ll have two options available which are to tell Otto von Bergow or reveal the betrayal.
Moreover, keep in mind that your previous choice will be a crucial piece to this quest. By mentioning the Semine wedding to escape von Bergow, you’re likely locked to confront the Semines. Plus, it’ll be extremely difficult to avert this situation and convince von Bergow to forget the matter.
The Critical Decision: Tell von Bergow or Stay Silent
Whether you decide to tell von Bergow or stay silent will be crucial to your gameplay. So, make sure to pick your side wisely to avoid further complications in the future. Here are the two options you’ll choose from and its outcome:
Option 1: Withholding Information (Recommended)
This choice is actually recommended to avoid causing unnecessary bloodshed in the game. By choosing to withhold information from von Bergow about Olda’s bandits’ involvement, you’ll skip bloody confrontation. Further, you’ll proceed directly to the next quest which is the “For Victory.”
Option 2: Revealing Semine’s Betrayal
In Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, choosing to reveal Olda Semine’s involvement with bandits results in conflict. Von Bergow will dispatch you alongside Hashek and his troop to confront the Semines. Further, you’ll have to make a choice which to side once you arrive at Semine’s place.
The Confrontation at Semine Estate
Now, once you are at the Semine estate, you’ll have to make another crucial choice. This ultimately will lead to bigger consequences as you’ll have to choose between Hashek’s side or the Semines. These will be the aftermath of your decision between Olda Samine and Hashek in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2.
Siding with Hashek
- A complete massacre of the Semine estate
- The death of all inhabitants, including Agnes (Olda’s bride)
- You’ll need to hunt down Olda on the top floor
- The estate gets burned down afterward
- You can report the full truth to von Bergow later
You’ll have to pick these dialogue options to side with Hashek in this quest:
- “Hashek is right”
- “We have a witness”
- “Listen to him, Semine!”
- “Hashek is right”
Siding with the Semines
- Fight Hashek and his men (with Hans Capon’s help)
- Help the Semines fake their deaths
- Burn down the estate as cover
- Lie to von Bergow about what happened
Now, choosing Semine’s side will require you to select these dialogue options:
- “We’ll sort it out peacefully”
- “You can’t do that!”
- “You’re going too far!”
- “I’m going to stop this”
Aftermath and Consequences
So, the question now is what will happen once you’ve chosen your side? After the confrontation, you’ll have to report back to von Bergow in the Maiden Tower. Ultimately, this will reveal two different aftermath and consequences for your choice:
If you sided with Semine:
- You can lie about the events (recommended)
- Confessing leads to Henry’s execution
- Von Bergow will condemn Hashek’s actions if you lie successfully
If you sided with Hashek:
- You can tell the full truth
- Option to condemn the massacre (costs reputation with von Bergow)
- Von Bergow will still criticize Hashek’s extreme methods
Recommended Choice
Overall, choosing to side with the Semines will ultimately benefit you and a better choice. Looking at the consequences, choosing Semine in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 will deliver greater benefit to society:
- Prevents the slaughter of innocent people
- Gives Olda a chance to explain his actions
- Maintains a cleaner conscience
- Allows for a more nuanced resolution
- Keeps Hans Capon’s respect
However, choose Hashek’s side to stick with your beliefs of serving justice at any cost. Yet, this will lead to brutal outcomes like bigger casualties.
Conclusion
Just keep in mind to choose wisely between Hashek and Semine in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2. Every decision will have an impact on your reputation that will affect your story’s progress. Definitely, you’ll have to think carefully about these options and weigh on your moral beliefs.
