Refining an armament for an All Damage roll in Rise of Kingdoms has no guaranteed cost or pity threshold, and spending 200 refinement stones can easily leave you without the stat. Instead of burning your entire stockpile on a single piece, stop chasing All Damage and keep functional rolls like troop Health and Defense on armaments with strong base stats.

Why 200 Refinement Stones Cannot Guarantee All Damage

Armament transmutation in the State Forum draws secondary attributes from an extensive, diluted stat pool. Each reroll pulls from every troop type—infantry, cavalry, archer, and siege—alongside non-combat utility stats like gathering speed, march speed, and barbarian damage.

Universal multipliers such as All Damage carry low probability weightings within this crowded pool. Because transmutation rolls multiple secondary slots simultaneously without bad-luck protection, high variance is unavoidable. Dedicated rolling sessions spending 200 or more stones regularly conclude without generating a single All Damage roll. Stockpiling 100 to 200 stones does not secure the modifier and frequently exhausts resources that could otherwise upgrade an entire march lineup.

All Damage vs. Standard Combat Attributes

All Damage is the top-tier secondary offensive stat because it functions as a universal amplifier across every damage phase. Specialized stats like Cavalry Attack or Skill Damage only enhance specific actions, whereas All Damage simultaneously scales:

  • Normal attacks
  • Counterattack damage when swarm-targeted in open-field battles
  • Primary active commander skill damage
  • Secondary commander skill procs and additional skill strikes

While commanders with high skill output—such as Guan Yu, Nevsky, or Scipio Prime—benefit heavily from this multiplier, the low acquisition rate makes chasing it inefficient. Passing on usable defensive attributes in pursuit of All Damage wastes rare refinement materials without delivering reliable power gains.

Secondary Attribute Priority: What to Keep

Refinement stones cannot be farmed continuously through standard daily play or alliance chests; they depend on State Forum activities, KvK seasonal rewards, and specific event shops. Wasting them by rolling past viable survivability stats lowers your field performance.

Pairing two Tier 2 survivability stats, such as Infantry Health and Infantry Defense, provides more immediate value on the open field than gambling for All Damage alongside unusable utility stats.

Attribute TierSecondary StatsEvaluation and Practical Usage
Tier 1 (Universal)All Damage dealtTop offensive modifier; amplifies normal, skill, and counterattack damage on any march.
Tier 2 (Core Meta)Troop Health, Troop DefenseHighest priority for trades; extends battlefield presence to sustain skill cycles.
Tier 3 (Viable Offensive)Skill Damage dealt, Counterattack Damage, Troop AttackSolid commander-specific performance; valuable for burst or swarm-heavy commanders.
Tier 4 (Dead Rolls)Gathering speed, Siege stats, Barbarian damageNo open-field combat value; reroll candidates.

Rules to Protect Your Refinement Stone Stockpile

To prevent depleting your stone inventory without improving your marches, apply structured session limits:

  1. Verify Base Quality First: Only refine legendary armaments that already possess high base attributes and match your active formation. Secondary stats cannot compensate for weak base values.
  2. Set a 30 to 40 Stone Session Cap: Limit refinement to a maximum of 30 to 40 stones per armament piece. If your target stats do not appear, halt the session rather than depleting your entire inventory in one attempt.
  3. Apply the Two-Stat Rule: Stop rolling immediately if an armament lands two relevant Tier 2 or Tier 3 stats matching your march type (such as Archer Health and Archer Skill Damage). Lock the armament and equip it.
  4. Equip Five Marches Before Optimizing One: Distribute usable Tier 2 and Tier 3 armaments across all five of your active open-field marches before attempting high-cost optimization on an individual commander pairing.
Rise of Kingdoms icon

Free Rise of Kingdoms Codes

Current active codes and how to redeem them.

View Codes
Sarah Williams

Sarah Williams

Sarah specializes in RPG and collection games, explaining team building, character growth, and beginner-friendly ways to avoid expensive early mistakes.